Top 93 Car Rental Companies in New York. 11 KPIs Compared.

Top 93 Rent-A-Car Companies in New York

Think of this as a "Best Car Rental Company in New York" contest. Except, here, a jury didn't get to choose who gets what. This time, we allowed all the 19,618,323 people living in New York to be a "juror" by picking up various signals they created, including Google search result rankings, online & offline sentiment metrics, reviews, citations, backlinks, brand mentions, social media activity, and more.

Let's not overcomplicate things. We're a digital marketing agency specializing in car rental SEO, with access to unique KPIs and hundreds of data points about every rent-a-car agency in America.

And this is essentially a popularity contest. We discovered & reviewed all the 214 car rentals in New York, then picked the most relevant 93 ones and ranked them according to their online presence. Okay, Okay, AI did that, but we helped too!

Unlock an unfair competitive advantage by subscribing to our newsletter, packed with unique New York car rental market insights and business intelligence!

Updated: November 12, 2024

Home → Blog → A side-by-side comparison of the best car rentals in New York (93 companies analyzed over 11 KPIs)

Changed your mind?

Car rentals | Rent-a-Car agencies, ranked by the good people of New York

Rank	Domain	PopulationServed	Visibility	AveragePosition	Pages	Rankings	ZIPs	Top1	Top3	Top10
#1	empirerac.com	1,883,970	9.6%	92.7	30	327	287	16	37	54
#2	momondo.com	600,965	3.1%	88.4	31	541	541	0	0	29
#3	allcarrentacar.com	549,973	2.8%	100.4	1	11	11	2	11	11
#4	4ezrental.com	455,752	2.3%	97.4	4	118	111	2	11	11
#5	sensiblecarrentalbklyn.com	308,019	1.6%	94.0	1	211	208	2	3	3
#6	carrentalexpress.com	266,892	1.4%	42.0	4	1756	1756	0	0	8
#7	alwaysamore.net	213,263	1.1%	100.8	2	4	3	2	3	3
#8	acerentacar.com	210,896	1.1%	46.3	2	1758	1756	1	2	2
#9	silvercar.com	182,159	0.9%	56.7	5	1593	1591	1	1	1
#10	europcar.com	168,736	0.9%	30.1	1	1756	1756	0	0	0
#11	antiquecarhire.com	156,173	0.8%	100.6	2	20	20	0	5	5
#12	discounthawaiicarrental.com	154,446	0.8%	37.9	1	1756	1756	0	0	0
#13	advantage.com	153,740	0.8%	38.5	1	1756	1756	0	0	0
#14	economybookings.com	152,089	0.8%	84.2	14	545	545	0	0	3
#15	autorentals.com	149,108	0.8%	57.4	2	1758	1756	1	2	2
#16	rentcars.com	145,853	0.7%	41.9	11	1754	1754	0	0	0
#17	luxuryonecorp.com	139,249	0.7%	100.9	1	2	2	1	2	2
#18	autoslash.com	136,809	0.7%	44.4	1	1616	1616	0	0	0
#19	discovercars.com	133,312	0.7%	44.7	1	1756	1756	0	0	0
#20	ddriveny.com	129,513	0.7%	100.9	1	2	2	0	2	2
#21	airportrentalcars.com	129,502	0.7%	44.9	1	1756	1756	0	0	0
#22	carrentalbronx.com	124,327	0.6%	100.9	1	2	2	0	2	2
#23	milescarrentalnewyork.com	115,461	0.6%	85.4	3	467	427	0	1	1
#24	speedyautorental.com	115,422	0.6%	100.5	2	18	17	1	2	2
#25	ccrentalnyc.com	110,709	0.6%	63.0	2	1716	1714	0	0	0
#26	aamcar.com	102,532	0.5%	72.9	2	1096	1096	0	0	0
#27	autoeurope.com	101,870	0.5%	59.4	5	1612	1612	0	0	0
#28	economyrentacar.com	100,727	0.5%	96.1	9	263	255	1	9	9
#29	joinbuggy.com	96,478	0.5%	95.7	4	821	820	0	1	1
#30	just4wheels.com	96,434	0.5%	100.8	5	20	20	0	2	2
#31	gwizz.com	77,376	0.4%	98.5	2	81	59	19	34	34
#32	sensiblecarrentalofkingston.com	69,206	0.4%	96.7	3	120	102	1	26	31
#33	budgettruck.com	54,608	0.3%	86.9	2	1720	1720	0	0	0
#34	happycar.com	53,361	0.3%	94.5	5	162	162	0	0	0
#35	realcar.nyc	49,391	0.3%	93.8	2	321	321	0	0	0
#36	turbe-car-rental.com	47,740	0.2%	86.1	1	1164	1164	0	0	0
#37	cloud9exotics.com	38,964	0.2%	93.6	1	1258	1258	0	0	0
#38	uandmycar.com	38,898	0.2%	100.7	1	6	6	0	6	6
#39	affiliatedcarrental.com	38,761	0.2%	98.0	9	177	177	0	2	4
#40	biracs.com	37,279	0.2%	100.9	1	1	1	1	1	1
#41	eurocars.com	32,663	0.2%	100.9	2	5	5	0	1	1
#42	imaginelifestyles.com	32,642	0.2%	100.9	1	2	2	0	1	1
#43	tiestorental.com	30,690	0.2%	100.9	1	1	1	0	1	1
#44	carrentalhawaii.com	27,677	0.1%	93.8	1	837	837	0	0	0
#45	valueautorental.com	27,616	0.1%	95.3	6	308	308	0	0	0
#46	milrentinc.com	24,661	0.1%	100.8	1	4	4	0	4	4
#47	bwrentacar.com	22,861	0.1%	92.7	1	320	320	0	0	0
#48	car2go.com	18,732	0.1%	96.9	3	751	751	0	0	0
#49	easirent.com	15,335	0.1%	96.8	2	435	435	0	0	0
#50	rentmajestic.com	14,416	0.1%	96.2	3	385	384	0	1	1
#51	vtivanrentals.com	13,640	0.1%	100.2	1	121	121	0	0	0
#52	carrental8.com	13,042	0.1%	95.4	1	178	178	0	0	0
#53	alexbayrentalcarandtrucksales.com	12,754	0.1%	100.5	1	10	8	7	8	8
#54	usavesayre.com	11,191	0.1%	100.8	1	4	4	2	4	4
#55	marathoncarrental.com	11,041	0.1%	99.7	1	39	39	0	0	0
#56	upstaterentalsllc.com	10,128	0.1%	100.9	1	2	2	1	2	2
#57	advancecarrental.com	9,934	0.1%	98.0	1	98	98	0	0	0
#58	courtesycarrental.com	8,662	0.0%	98.7	1	328	328	0	0	0
#59	dixonscarandtruckrental.com	8,171	0.0%	100.8	1	3	3	0	3	3
#60	rentalcar.com	5,938	0.0%	99.4	1	150	150	0	0	0
#61	vtcarrental.com	5,292	0.0%	100.7	2	15	14	0	2	2
#62	kuehnrentals.com	4,799	0.0%	99.5	1	44	44	0	0	0
#63	holidaycars.com	4,781	0.0%	99.5	4	122	122	0	0	0
#64	americanlease.com	4,594	0.0%	100.8	1	25	25	0	0	0
#65	cityrentacar.com	3,956	0.0%	100.0	1	99	99	0	0	0
#66	journeyrentacar.com	3,686	0.0%	99.9	1	84	84	0	0	0
#67	bonzah.com	2,862	0.0%	100.5	1	116	116	0	0	0
#68	alaskaautorental.com	2,802	0.0%	100.2	1	79	79	0	0	0
#69	stamfordrentacar.com	2,483	0.0%	100.2	2	46	46	0	0	0
#70	broadwaysupercars.com	2,368	0.0%	100.8	1	17	17	0	0	0
#71	carsmart.rentals	1,510	0.0%	100.8	2	28	28	0	0	0
#72	fairmounttruckrental.com	1,371	0.0%	100.9	1	23	23	0	0	0
#73	theexoticcarrentalbusiness.com	1,115	0.0%	100.9	1	1	1	0	1	1
#74	cagrentalcar.com	532	0.0%	100.8	1	17	17	0	0	0
#75	ccrentalnj.com	518	0.0%	101.0	1	10	10	0	0	0
#76	drivo.com	406	0.0%	100.9	2	9	9	0	0	0
#77	cheaperthancars.com	342	0.0%	101.0	1	7	7	0	0	0
#78	motionrentalcars.com	211	0.0%	101.0	1	3	3	0	0	0
#79	harbroauto.com	205	0.0%	101.0	1	1	1	0	0	0
#80	comfortvehicles.com	154	0.0%	100.9	1	1	1	0	1	1
#81	korexcar.com	128	0.0%	101.0	1	3	3	0	0	0
#82	rentacargreenwich.com	99	0.0%	101.0	1	2	2	0	0	0
#83	hyrecar.com	82	0.0%	101.0	1	8	8	0	0	0
#84	xpressrentalcarofkanab.com	65	0.0%	101.0	1	1	1	0	0	0
#85	performancerentals.us	58	0.0%	101.0	1	6	6	0	0	0
#86	usacarsrental.com	52	0.0%	101.0	2	2	2	0	0	0
#87	bookinggroup.com	20	0.0%	101.0	1	1	1	0	0	0
#88	advantagecarrentals.com	18	0.0%	101.0	2	3	3	0	0	0
#89	mauicarrental.com	12	0.0%	101.0	1	1	1	0	0	0
#90	transcanadacarrental.com	9	0.0%	101.0	1	2	2	0	0	0
#91	beckstowingandauto.com	5	0.0%	101.0	1	1	1	0	0	0
#92	dryve.nyc	3	0.0%	101.0	1	1	1	0	0	0
#93	blackcarrentalnyc.com	1	0.0%	101.0	1	1	1	0	0	0

What next? Let's see how SEOlium can help your business.

If you own, manage, or work for a car rental business, this section is for you.

Want your backlink switched from nofollow to 'dofollow'? Drop us a message at info@seolium.com.
Need help with improving your metrics above (SEO consultancy & implementation)? Feel free to reach out at info@seolium.com.
Have an in-house SEO team? Our 99.7% accurate local Google rank tracking tool will help you track & report everything properly.

Interested in the New York rent-a-car industry dynamics (market fluctuations, trends & emerging players, month-to-month movements)?