Top 150 Insurance Companies (+ Agents/Brokers) in The USA

Top 150 Insurance Companies, Agencies, And Brokers in The United States

Think of this as an "Insurance Company Of The Month" contest. Except here, a jury didn't get to choose who gets what. This time, we allowed all the 322,871,369 people living in USA to be jurors by picking up various signals they created, including reviews, online & offline sentiment metrics, citations, Google search result rankings, links between websites, brand mentions, social media activity, and more.

Essentially, this competition focuses on the passion for providing peace of mind and financial security to businesses and individuals. We discovered and reviewed all 8,137 insurance providers (insurers, agents, brokers, consultants, etc.) in USA, then shortlisted 150 who offer a range of services, including auto insurance, homeowners insurance, health & life insurance, disability insurance, and more. Finally, we ranked them based on their track record, transparency, customer satisfaction rating, claims process, and financial stability.

Unlock an unfair competitive advantage by subscribing to our newsletter, packed with unique USA insurance market insights and business intelligence!

Updated: November 6, 2024

Home → Blog → Side-by-side comparison of the best insurance companies in the US

Changed your mind?

Insurance agencies & companies, ranked by the good people of USA

Rank	Domain	PopulationServed	Visibility	AveragePosition	States	Cities	Pages	Rankings	ZIPs	Top1	Top3	Top10
#1	allstate.com	247,320,212	76.6%	3.3	51	27379	442	35050	32654	7396	9043	35049
#2	nationwide.com	212,408,410	65.8%	4.4	51	27379	516	34341	32654	628	6630	34341
#3	geico.com	151,068,698	46.8%	6.5	51	27379	14	32700	32654	7	2274	32700
#4	esurance.com	141,209,874	43.7%	6.6	51	27379	3	32660	32654	3	1384	32660
#5	farmers.com	135,471,613	42.0%	6.8	51	27379	477	34256	32654	402	2491	34253
#6	libertymutual.com	88,254,769	27.3%	8.2	51	27379	8	32683	32654	11	181	32680
#7	progressive.com	50,255,494	15.6%	9.7	51	27379	39	32951	32654	84	293	27651
#8	statefarm.com	43,019,092	13.3%	10.5	51	27379	111	33580	32654	270	894	10766
#9	travelers.com	23,329,287	7.2%	12.9	51	27379	5	32668	32654	2	13	2993
#10	safeco.com	18,606,630	5.8%	15.3	51	27379	7	32680	32654	5	26	1865
#11	aig.com	18,135,434	5.6%	14.5	51	27379	5	32669	32654	8	15	46
#12	americannational.com	15,962,984	4.9%	18.3	51	27379	98	34089	32654	521	1388	1438
#13	amica.com	13,526,362	4.2%	17.0	51	27379	27	32856	32654	83	195	218
#14	prudential.com	11,887,375	3.7%	30.0	51	27379	60	33762	32654	411	1093	1107
#15	firstam.com	10,765,126	3.3%	73.2	51	27379	107	33361	32654	187	679	706
#16	central-insurance.com	10,066,404	3.1%	17.5	51	27379	2	32664	32654	3	10	15
#17	infinityauto.com	7,289,093	2.3%	19.8	51	27379	3	32661	32654	3	7	7
#18	newyorklife.com	7,032,119	2.2%	31.8	51	27379	28	33012	32654	100	338	358
#19	chubb.com	6,709,862	2.1%	22.0	51	27379	5	32724	32654	20	68	70
#20	txfb-ins.com	6,441,551	2.0%	70.1	51	27379	6	33445	32654	292	764	791
#21	aflac.com	6,058,575	1.9%	24.4	51	27379	162	32973	32654	91	317	319
#22	acceptanceinsurance.com	5,877,337	1.8%	99.8	15	324	132	417	413	97	404	417
#23	mapfreinsurance.com	5,710,901	1.8%	20.6	51	27379	2	32656	32654	1	2	91
#24	guardianlife.com	5,003,801	1.5%	26.9	51	27379	4	32776	32654	40	117	122
#25	anico.com	4,840,455	1.5%	99.7	27	353	1	428	422	164	410	428
#26	amfam.com	4,793,492	1.5%	76.0	51	22098	91	26642	26069	156	709	742
#27	metlife.com	4,649,695	1.4%	24.0	51	27379	11	32789	32654	34	130	135
#28	horacemann.com	4,526,692	1.4%	99.3	41	529	23	559	550	211	539	559
#29	erieinsurance.com	4,516,073	1.4%	41.0	51	27378	97	32981	32653	103	321	331
#30	electricinsurance.com	4,430,643	1.4%	20.5	51	27379	2	32655	32654	0	1	1
#31	westfieldinsurance.com	3,882,815	1.2%	25.2	51	27379	5	32717	32654	20	63	63
#32	aetna.com	3,797,059	1.2%	22.3	51	27379	1	32656	32654	0	2	2
#33	arbella.com	3,636,882	1.1%	36.5	51	27377	7	32669	32652	4	16	77
#34	greatamericaninsurancegroup.com	3,618,475	1.1%	32.6	51	27379	2	32758	32654	28	85	104
#35	selective.com	3,244,555	1.0%	28.8	51	27379	4	32672	32654	4	18	18
#36	safetyinsurance.com	2,914,080	0.9%	38.5	51	27372	1	32647	32647	0	0	4
#37	njm.com	2,895,958	0.9%	46.0	51	27377	2	32656	32651	2	5	28
#38	federatedinsurance.com	2,862,018	0.9%	33.6	51	27379	3	32668	32654	6	13	13
#39	grangeinsurance.com	2,804,885	0.9%	38.9	51	27379	1	32660	32654	2	6	14
#40	agencyinsurancecompany.com	2,743,374	0.8%	38.8	51	27370	1	32642	32642	0	0	3
#41	massmutual.com	2,735,531	0.8%	35.0	51	27379	1	32663	32654	5	9	9
#42	churchmutual.com	2,641,497	0.8%	36.8	51	27375	1	32648	32647	0	1	1
#43	ruralmutual.com	2,632,888	0.8%	47.3	51	27379	32	32723	32654	19	66	69
#44	cna.com	2,629,373	0.8%	37.8	51	27379	1	32659	32654	3	5	5
#45	cigna.com	2,606,310	0.8%	40.0	51	27379	1	32673	32653	4	20	20
#46	standard.com	2,532,702	0.8%	54.2	51	27364	3	32653	32634	8	19	19
#47	pacificlife.com	2,513,294	0.8%	54.0	51	27378	2	32676	32651	12	25	25
#48	ailife.com	2,327,829	0.7%	52.1	51	27379	4	32664	32654	1	10	10
#49	icwgroup.com	2,313,622	0.7%	50.6	51	27379	2	32657	32654	0	3	3
#50	mercuryinsurance.com	2,255,019	0.7%	67.1	51	27368	18	32677	32639	15	38	38
#51	foremost.com	2,247,219	0.7%	51.7	51	27376	2	32656	32651	2	5	5
#52	coloniallife.com	2,196,404	0.7%	54.9	51	27379	4	32660	32654	2	6	6
#53	wawanesa.com	2,193,883	0.7%	51.1	51	27345	1	32609	32609	0	0	0
#54	directauto.com	2,186,766	0.7%	100.5	12	147	65	179	179	35	171	179
#55	cinfin.com	2,182,304	0.7%	54.1	51	27378	4	32685	32652	13	33	37
#56	lancerinsurance.com	2,152,138	0.7%	55.0	51	27301	2	32558	32556	1	2	2
#57	patriotinsuranceco.com	2,133,220	0.7%	51.4	51	25117	1	29819	29814	1	5	5
#58	anthem.com	2,115,489	0.7%	53.0	51	27379	1	32666	32654	4	12	12
#59	farmersagent.com	2,113,089	0.7%	100.4	25	179	70	194	194	47	188	194
#60	allianzlife.com	2,104,700	0.7%	54.4	51	27378	2	32653	32652	0	1	1
#61	northwesternmutual.com	2,079,320	0.6%	51.8	51	27378	1	32653	32652	0	1	1
#62	mutualofomaha.com	2,075,112	0.6%	99.8	47	452	36	476	468	129	361	380
#63	fredloya.com	2,068,768	0.6%	100.8	7	65	2	83	82	18	79	83
#64	shelterinsurance.com	2,058,279	0.6%	99.6	17	469	95	491	476	148	482	491
#65	lexingtoninsurance.com	2,038,380	0.6%	56.1	51	26395	1	31439	31439	0	0	0
#66	ceiwc.com	2,032,412	0.6%	60.4	51	27379	1	32661	32652	5	9	9
#67	sublimityins.com	2,016,270	0.6%	57.0	51	25846	1	30750	30741	3	8	9
#68	archcapgroup.com	1,990,643	0.6%	58.3	51	27367	2	32643	32642	0	1	1
#69	fmic.com	1,966,748	0.6%	58.0	51	27302	2	32558	32557	0	1	1
#70	rlicorp.com	1,960,794	0.6%	92.0	51	27377	2	32703	32652	19	51	51
#71	freewayinsurance.com	1,920,501	0.6%	100.7	14	80	60	115	114	19	109	114
#72	canalinsurance.com	1,917,149	0.6%	63.0	51	27008	2	32209	32200	4	9	9
#73	aaalife.com	1,906,761	0.6%	63.1	51	27379	1	32655	32654	1	1	1
#74	uhc.com	1,769,702	0.5%	64.2	51	27379	1	32655	32654	1	1	1
#75	vafb.com	1,743,915	0.5%	99.9	6	363	3	417	377	132	406	417
#76	unitedamerican.com	1,721,067	0.5%	100.7	17	89	3	102	102	29	95	101
#77	allstateagencies.com	1,666,805	0.5%	100.0	33	337	81	340	340	114	327	340
#78	zurichna.com	1,660,916	0.5%	71.3	51	27379	2	32656	32654	1	2	2
#79	transamerica.com	1,641,327	0.5%	70.1	51	27379	2	32657	32654	0	3	3
#80	auto-owners.com	1,626,831	0.5%	100.6	15	107	4	125	121	30	124	125
#81	donegalgroup.com	1,613,968	0.5%	69.2	51	27379	2	32665	32654	2	11	11
#82	meemic.com	1,606,459	0.5%	75.7	51	27379	3	32677	32654	7	23	23
#83	ctic.com	1,584,750	0.5%	97.3	51	27289	4	32602	32534	15	64	68
#84	remco.com	1,507,092	0.5%	100.7	1	76	8	119	112	34	113	119
#85	guard.com	1,501,840	0.5%	72.3	51	27379	1	32655	32654	0	1	1
#86	northstarmutual.com	1,493,199	0.5%	72.5	51	27303	2	32560	32558	0	2	2
#87	thehartford.com	1,480,034	0.5%	77.6	51	27379	6	32663	32654	2	9	9
#88	acuity.com	1,459,501	0.5%	75.4	51	27301	1	32558	32556	0	2	2
#89	phly.com	1,453,849	0.5%	100.7	24	60	6	123	115	19	70	73
#90	thegeneral.com	1,312,738	0.4%	97.1	51	27264	5	32528	32486	19	42	42
#91	alfainsurance.com	1,292,563	0.4%	100.4	7	180	42	190	185	47	182	190
#92	usagencies.com	1,288,955	0.4%	100.6	3	96	35	124	121	29	120	124
#93	huntington.com	1,278,014	0.4%	100.4	7	196	3	208	204	56	206	208
#94	countryfinancial.com	1,273,401	0.4%	100.3	12	221	83	226	225	62	219	226
#95	pennmutual.com	1,259,496	0.4%	91.5	51	27352	1	32656	32622	16	33	34
#96	assurity.com	1,205,429	0.4%	83.3	51	27300	2	32565	32555	2	10	10
#97	combinedinsurance.com	1,190,627	0.4%	84.9	51	27277	3	32536	32529	0	7	7
#98	lawyersmutual.com	1,144,030	0.4%	100.8	2	38	1	50	50	26	41	50
#99	accidentfund.com	1,107,056	0.3%	85.1	51	27379	2	32656	32654	0	2	2
#100	usaa.com	1,105,545	0.3%	84.8	51	27379	1	32654	32654	0	0	0
#101	lainsurance.com	1,091,303	0.3%	100.9	4	32	4	49	48	5	49	49
#102	nglic.com	1,028,179	0.3%	85.1	51	22473	2	26541	26539	1	2	2
#103	safeauto.com	1,011,466	0.3%	83.1	51	15239	2	17684	17682	1	3	3
#104	humana.com	989,061	0.3%	89.9	51	27378	1	32662	32653	2	9	9
#105	anpac.com	979,619	0.3%	100.7	18	86	11	96	94	27	94	96
#106	deltadentalins.com	975,199	0.3%	88.8	51	27379	1	32654	32654	0	0	0
#107	nationallife.com	924,605	0.3%	99.0	51	26469	2	31436	31400	9	35	36
#108	hiscox.com	894,636	0.3%	89.8	51	25505	2	30205	30204	1	1	1
#109	hanover.com	886,922	0.3%	100.8	24	94	6	102	101	15	61	63
#110	protective.com	873,929	0.3%	92.6	51	15873	2	18458	18447	5	19	20
#111	unum.com	810,245	0.3%	93.6	51	27370	1	32641	32640	1	1	1
#112	progressiveagent.com	791,556	0.2%	100.4	32	176	71	182	182	55	172	182
#113	joinroot.com	788,922	0.2%	86.7	51	15606	1	18089	18089	0	0	0
#114	illinoisvehicle.com	754,805	0.2%	100.9	1	32	16	43	42	18	43	43
#115	greatflorida.com	750,486	0.2%	100.8	1	39	27	52	51	13	52	52
#116	veloxinsurance.com	743,575	0.2%	100.9	2	25	14	31	31	6	31	31
#117	germaniainsurance.com	735,871	0.2%	93.7	51	13051	4	14921	14897	21	54	55
#118	cheapcarinsurance.net	722,514	0.2%	100.9	9	26	9	38	38	11	36	38
#119	ameritas.com	706,618	0.2%	95.2	51	24074	2	28214	28213	0	1	1
#120	admiralins.com	706,079	0.2%	91.3	51	14844	2	17167	17166	1	2	2
#121	standardinsurance.net	654,463	0.2%	100.8	2	39	2	55	54	19	55	55
#122	prontoinsurance.com	625,916	0.2%	100.9	2	24	6	27	27	7	27	27
#123	yourlifesecure.com	592,588	0.2%	96.5	51	20804	2	24449	24448	0	1	1
#124	premierinsuranceagency.com	590,058	0.2%	100.9	11	35	3	41	41	8	41	41
#125	plymouthrock.com	587,857	0.2%	100.9	5	34	4	37	37	12	37	37
#126	alliedinsurance.com	585,302	0.2%	100.6	23	127	2	130	130	54	126	130
#127	mcgriffinsurance.com	564,163	0.2%	100.7	12	101	1	101	101	27	100	101
#128	abcautoinsurance.com	546,698	0.2%	100.9	13	40	1	44	44	14	44	44
#129	kclife.com	539,581	0.2%	91.0	51	8365	1	9494	9494	1	2	2
#130	sentry.com	539,391	0.2%	100.8	9	112	1	142	142	11	25	25
#131	a-affordableinsurance.com	532,662	0.2%	100.9	2	19	2	23	23	7	22	23
#132	an.insure	531,561	0.2%	100.8	15	72	17	75	75	15	70	75
#133	emcins.com	506,039	0.2%	100.9	7	35	3	49	49	15	47	49
#134	mutualofenumclaw.com	503,194	0.2%	100.9	5	26	2	31	31	9	29	31
#135	ficoh.com	471,070	0.1%	100.9	3	29	2	43	39	13	25	35
#136	texasmutual.com	465,497	0.1%	97.0	48	2190	2	2802	2788	6	14	14
#137	nodakins.com	445,013	0.1%	100.4	8	184	10	216	190	60	199	212
#138	farmfamily.com	429,454	0.1%	100.7	9	101	3	101	101	31	99	101
#139	arnoldic.com	398,010	0.1%	100.8	5	64	2	83	68	31	83	83
#140	caiautoinsurance.com	393,265	0.1%	100.9	1	21	2	34	28	8	32	34
#141	advantage1auto.com	388,912	0.1%	100.9	2	22	2	26	26	6	26	26
#142	directgeneral.com	378,579	0.1%	100.9	9	20	6	23	23	7	23	23
#143	aisinsurance.com	374,992	0.1%	101.0	5	8	1	13	13	5	13	13
#144	ific.com	359,000	0.1%	101.0	6	12	2	14	14	6	14	14
#145	libertynational.com	350,446	0.1%	100.9	7	18	1	20	20	5	19	20
#146	ctlowndes.com	345,941	0.1%	100.9	1	28	8	35	31	13	35	35
#147	farmersunioninsurance.com	342,520	0.1%	100.4	12	196	22	201	196	57	187	201
#148	fbitn.com	341,017	0.1%	100.8	3	50	28	51	50	15	50	51
#149	badgermutual.com	340,096	0.1%	101.0	1	3	1	15	15	8	15	15
#150	naucountry.com	338,410	0.1%	99.0	51	5406	2	6068	6065	1	10	10

What next? Let's see how SEOlium can help your business.

If you are an insurance broker or own, manage, or work for an insurance agency/company, this section is for you.

Want your backlink switched from nofollow to 'dofollow'? Drop us a message at info@seolium.com.
Need help with improving your metrics above (SEO consultancy & implementation)? Feel free to reach out at info@seolium.com.
Have an in-house SEO team? Our 99.7% accurate local Google rank tracking tool will help you track & report everything properly.

Interested in the USA insurance industry dynamics (market fluctuations, trends & emerging players, month-to-month movements)?